I’ve tried hundreds of eyeliners as a beauty editor and nothing beats the £3 fave I found aged 14

If you’re on the hunt for the perfect eyeliner, look no further. As a beauty editor, I’ve tried hundreds of eyeliners, and let me tell you, nothing beats the £3 favorite that I discovered when I was just 14 years old. This budget-friendly find has stood the test of time and continues to be my go-to for achieving the perfect cat-eye or smoky look. In this article, I’ll share my personal experience with this incredible eyeliner and why it has become a staple in my makeup routine. Get ready to revolutionize your eyeliner game with this affordable gem.

Table of Contents

Eyeliner Favorites


Eyeliner is a staple in many people’s makeup routines. It adds definition, drama, and can completely transform your look. Whether you prefer a subtle, natural line or a bold, winged cat-eye, finding the perfect eyeliner is essential. In this article, we will explore the importance of eyeliner, share some tips and tricks for application, discuss different eyeliner styles, and recommend our favorite affordable option.

Importance of Eyeliner

Eyeliner is a versatile tool that can enhance the appearance of the eyes in various ways. It can make your eyes look bigger, accentuate your natural eye shape, and even change the overall mood of your makeup look. Eyeliner can be used to create a wide range of styles, from natural and understated to bold and dramatic. It is a must-have product for anyone looking to elevate their eye makeup game.

Ive tried hundreds of eyeliners as a beauty editor and nothing beats the £3 fave I found aged 14

The Search for the Perfect Eyeliner

Finding the perfect eyeliner can be a daunting task. There are countless options available, each with its own unique formula, applicator, and finish. Some eyeliners smudge easily, while others fade quickly throughout the day. It can be frustrating to invest in a high-end eyeliner only to be disappointed by its performance. However, with a bit of experimentation and research, you can find an eyeliner that meets all your needs.

Discovery of the £3 Favorite

After trying numerous high-end eyeliners as a beauty editor, one eyeliner stood out among the rest: a £3 gem that was discovered at the tender age of 14. This budget-friendly eyeliner delivers exceptional performance at a fraction of the cost of its high-end counterparts. Its quality, longevity, and ease of application make it a favorite among makeup enthusiasts.

Ive tried hundreds of eyeliners as a beauty editor and nothing beats the £3 fave I found aged 14

Benefits of the £3 Eyeliner

The £3 eyeliner offers a range of benefits that make it a standout product in the market.

Longevity and Durability

One of the most impressive aspects of the £3 eyeliner is its longevity. It stays put for hours without smudging or fading, even in humid weather or on oily eyelids. This saves you the hassle of constant touch-ups and ensures that your eyeliner remains flawless throughout the day.

Ease of Application

The £3 eyeliner glides on smoothly and effortlessly, making it a dream to apply. Its precise applicator allows for precise lines, whether you’re going for a thin and subtle look or a bold and dramatic wing. The formula is also forgiving, allowing you to fix any mistakes without having to start from scratch.

Rich Pigmentation

Despite its affordable price, the £3 eyeliner boasts rich pigmentation. It delivers intense color payoff with just one swipe, so you don’t have to layer the product to achieve the desired intensity. This saves you both time and product, making it a cost-effective option.

Variety of Shades

The £3 eyeliner comes in a wide range of shades to suit every preference and occasion. From basic black and brown to vibrant blues and purples, you can find the perfect shade to complement your eye color and overall makeup look. This versatility allows you to experiment and have fun with your eyeliner.


Perhaps the biggest advantage of the £3 eyeliner is its affordability. While high-end eyeliners can cost a fortune, this budget-friendly option allows you to achieve professional-looking results without breaking the bank. It is a great option for those on a tight budget or anyone who doesn’t want to splurge on an expensive eyeliner.

Comparison with Other Eyeliners

To truly understand the value of the £3 eyeliner, we decided to put it to the test against other high-end brands. We compared the price, quality, performance, application techniques, pigmentation, and shade range of various eyeliners on the market.

Testing Other High-End Brands

We selected a range of high-end eyeliners from different brands to compare their performance to the £3 favorite. These eyeliners were chosen based on their popularity, positive reviews, and claims of long-lasting wear.

Comparison of Price and Quality

We analyzed the price and quality of each eyeliner, considering factors such as packaging, formula, and overall user experience. While some high-end eyeliners offered luxurious packaging and innovative formulas, they often fell short in terms of performance and longevity.

Performance and Endurance

We wore each eyeliner for an extended period to test its performance and endurance. We evaluated factors such as smudging, fading, and transfer throughout the day. The £3 favorite consistently outperformed its high-end counterparts, proving that price does not always equate to quality.

Comparison of Application Techniques

We tested different application techniques with each eyeliner, including thin lines, thick lines, and winged liner. We assessed how easily the product glided on, how precise the lines were, and how forgiving the formula was for mistakes. The £3 eyeliner excelled in all categories, making it the clear winner in terms of ease of application.

Comparison of Pigmentation

We swatched each eyeliner to compare the pigmentation and color payoff. The £3 favorite delivered rich, intense colors with just one swipe, outperforming many high-end eyeliners that required multiple layers to achieve the same level of pigmentation.

Comparison of Shade Range

We explored the shade range of each eyeliner and compared the variety of options available. While some high-end brands offered a decent range of colors, the £3 favorite surpassed them with its extensive selection. It truly catered to a wide range of preferences and allowed for endless creativity.

Overall Value for Money

After carefully considering all factors, including performance, price, and variety, it was evident that the £3 eyeliner offered the best value for money. Its affordability, combined with its exceptional quality, made it the top choice among all the eyeliners tested.

Ive tried hundreds of eyeliners as a beauty editor and nothing beats the £3 fave I found aged 14

Eyeliner Tips and Tricks

Now that we’ve discovered the perfect eyeliner, let’s explore some tips and tricks to help you achieve flawless application.

Prepping the Eyes

Before applying eyeliner, it’s important to prep your eyes to ensure smooth and long-lasting wear. Start by cleansing your eyelids to remove any oil or debris. Then, apply an eyeshadow primer to create a smooth base and prevent smudging. Finally, set the primer with a translucent powder to ensure your eyeliner stays in place.

Choosing the Right Formula

There are various eyeliner formulas to choose from, including pencil, gel, liquid, and pen. Each formula has its own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to choose one that suits your needs and preferences. Pencil eyeliners are great for beginners and provide a soft, smudged look, while gel and liquid formulas offer precise, long-lasting lines.

Selecting the Appropriate Brush or Pencil

The applicator you use can greatly impact the look and ease of your eyeliner application. For pencil eyeliners, opt for a sharp, fine-pointed pencil for precise lines. Gel eyeliners require an angled brush to achieve a clean, winged look, while liquid eyeliners usually come with a fine-tip brush for easy application.

Applying Different Styles of Eyeliner

There are various eyeliner styles to choose from, depending on the look you want to achieve. For a classic look, try a thin line along the lash line. To create a winged look, start by drawing a thin line from the inner corner and gradually increasing the thickness towards the outer corner. Use a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover to correct any mistakes or smudges.

Fixing Mistakes and Smudges

Eyeliner application can be tricky, and mistakes are bound to happen. If you make a mistake or end up with a smudge, don’t panic. Simply dip a cotton swab in makeup remover and gently clean up the area. For more stubborn mistakes, use a concealer or foundation brush dipped in makeup remover to precisely remove the unwanted eyeliner.

Enhancing Eyeliner with Other Makeup Products

Eyeliner can be enhanced by pairing it with other makeup products. For a smoky eye look, smudge the eyeliner with a small smudging brush or a cotton swab. Add eyeshadow in complementary shades to create depth and dimension. You can also amp up your eyeliner by adding glitter or applying false lashes to further enhance your eye makeup.

Eyeliner for Beginners

If you’re new to eyeliner, don’t worry! With a bit of practice and some guidance, you’ll be rocking the perfect winged liner in no time.

Understanding Different Types of Eyeliners

There are various types of eyeliners available, each with its own unique characteristics. Pencil eyeliners are the most beginner-friendly, as they offer more control and are easier to smudge. Liquid and gel eyeliners provide sharper, more precise lines, but can be more challenging to master.

Choosing the Right Eyeliner Style

Not all eyeliner styles will suit your eye shape and personal preferences. Experiment with different styles, such as thin lines, winged liner, or a smudged look, to find what works best for you. Consider your eye shape, natural crease, and desired level of drama when selecting an eyeliner style.

Step-by-Step Application Guide

Beginners often struggle with applying eyeliner evenly and creating symmetrical lines. To make the process easier, start by mapping out the desired shape with small dots along the upper lash line. Connect the dots using small, short strokes, gradually building up the thickness and wing. Use a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover to clean up any mistakes.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

There are a few common mistakes that beginners tend to make when applying eyeliner. One of the most common is pulling the eyelid taut, which can result in uneven lines. Another mistake is applying too much pressure, resulting in a thick and overly intense line. Practice applying eyeliner with a light hand and gradually build up the intensity.

Tips for a Long-Lasting and Smudge-Proof Application

To ensure your eyeliner lasts all day without smudging, there are a few additional tips you can follow. First, always apply eyeshadow primer to create a smooth base and prevent creasing. Set the primer with a translucent powder to absorb any excess oil. If you have oily eyelids, consider using a waterproof or long-wearing eyeliner formula. Finally, avoid touching or rubbing your eyes throughout the day to prevent smudging.

Ive tried hundreds of eyeliners as a beauty editor and nothing beats the £3 fave I found aged 14

Eyeliner as a Beauty Staple

Eyeliner is a versatile tool that can be used in various ways to enhance your overall makeup look.

Versatility of Eyeliner

Eyeliner offers endless possibilities for creativity and experimentation. You can create a wide range of looks, from subtle and natural to bold and dramatic, simply by adjusting the thickness, shape, and placement of your liner. It is a versatile tool that allows you to express your personal style and elevate your makeup game.

Eyeliner as a Statement Look

For those who love to make a statement, eyeliner can be the star of your makeup look. A bold, winged cat-eye or a graphic liner design can instantly grab attention and add a touch of drama to any outfit or occasion. Experiment with different colors, textures, and finishes to create unique and eye-catching looks.

Eyeliner for Everyday Makeup

While eyeliner can certainly be bold and dramatic, it can also be incorporated into your everyday makeup routine for a more subtle and polished look. A thin line of eyeliner along the upper lash line can make your eyes appear larger and more awake, without being overpowering. It adds a touch of definition and elegance to any daytime look.

Eyeliner as an Accentuating Tool

Eyeliner can be used to accentuate your natural eye shape and color. Different liner techniques can enhance your eyes in various ways. For example, a winged liner can lift and elongate downturned eyes, while tightlining can make your lash line appear fuller and more voluminous. Play around with different techniques to find what works best for you.

Tips for Eyeliner Application on Different Eye Shapes

Different eye shapes require different techniques and styles of eyeliner application to enhance their natural beauty.

Almond-Shaped Eyes

Almond-shaped eyes are considered the most versatile eye shape, as most eyeliner styles and techniques complement this shape. Experiment with different styles, such as winged liner or a smudged look, to enhance the natural shape and create more definition.

Hooded Eyes

Hooded eyes have a less visible eyelid due to excess skin that droops over the crease. To make your eyes appear more awake and defined, focus on tightlining along the upper lash line and creating a subtle winged liner. Avoid applying thick lines or too much product on the eyelid, as it can make the eyes look smaller.

Monolid Eyes

Monolid eyes have a flat eyelid without a visible crease. To add dimension and create the illusion of a crease, apply a thin line of eyeliner close to the lash line, gradually thickening towards the outer corner. A winged liner can also elongate the eyes and make them appear more lifted.

Round Eyes

Round eyes have a wider appearance and are often characterized by a prominent curve. To elongate and balance the eyes, create a winged liner that extends slightly beyond the outer corner. Avoid applying thick lines along the lower lash line, as it can make the eyes appear rounder.

Downturned Eyes

Downturned eyes have a slight droop at the outer corners, creating a sad or tired appearance. To lift and open up the eyes, focus on creating a winged liner that flicks upward. Extend the wing slightly higher than the natural eye shape to create a subtle lift.

Upturned Eyes

Upturned eyes have a slight upward tilt at the outer corners. To enhance this natural shape, create a winged liner that follows the upward curve of the eyes. Avoid extending the wing too far downward, as it can make the eyes appear droopy.

Ive tried hundreds of eyeliners as a beauty editor and nothing beats the £3 fave I found aged 14

The Evolution of Eyeliner Trends

Eyeliner trends have evolved over the years, reflecting the changing preferences and influences of different eras.

Historical Context

Eyeliner has a rich history that dates back to ancient civilizations. Egyptians were known for their iconic winged liner, created using kohl or other natural pigments. In ancient Greece and Rome, eyeliner was used to enhance the eyes and symbolize wealth and status. Eyeliner has continued to evolve throughout history, adapting to cultural, societal, and fashion trends.

Classic Winged Liner

The classic winged liner, also known as the cat-eye, has remained a timeless and iconic eyeliner style. It exudes elegance and sophistication, and can be adapted to suit any occasion. The winged liner has been popularized by Hollywood icons such as Audrey Hepburn and Brigitte Bardot, and continues to be a staple in many makeup routines.

Graphic and Artistic Liner

In recent years, eyeliner trends have taken a more artistic and creative turn. From graphic liner designs to intricate geometric shapes, eyeliner has become a canvas for self-expression. This trend has been fueled by social media platforms, such as Instagram and TikTok, where makeup enthusiasts share their bold and artistic creations.

Influence of Pop Culture and Celebrities

Pop culture and celebrities have a significant influence on eyeliner trends. Iconic makeup looks from the red carpet, music videos, and movies often inspire trends that trickle down to everyday makeup wearers. Celebrities such as Adele, Amy Winehouse, and Ariana Grande have popularized specific eyeliner styles, leading to widespread adoption and imitation.

Current Trends and the Return of Retro Styles

Current eyeliner trends embrace a mix of old and new styles. Retro looks from the ’60s and ’70s, such as thick, winged liner and graphic shapes, have made a comeback in recent years. At the same time, minimalist and subtle eyeliner styles have gained popularity, catering to those who prefer a more natural and understated look.

Eyeliner in the Beauty Industry

Eyeliner holds a significant place in the beauty industry, with its popularity and demand continuously growing.

Eyeliner as a Bestselling Product

Eyeliner is consistently one of the bestselling makeup products, coveted by makeup enthusiasts and beginners alike. Its versatility, ease of use, and ability to transform a look make it a must-have item in everyone’s makeup bag. The demand for eyeliner has led beauty brands to develop innovative formulas, applicators, and finishes to cater to the diverse needs and preferences of consumers.

Influence of Beauty Bloggers and Influencers

The rise of beauty bloggers and influencers has played a crucial role in shaping eyeliner trends and driving product sales. These individuals have huge followings on social media platforms and often collaborate with beauty brands to create limited edition products or promote existing ones. Their recommendations, tutorials, and reviews greatly influence consumer purchasing decisions.

Eyeliner Collaborations and Limited Edition Releases

Beauty brands frequently collaborate with celebrities, influencers, and makeup artists to create limited edition eyeliner collections. These collaborations generate excitement and anticipation among makeup enthusiasts and often lead to sold-out products. Limited edition releases provide opportunities for unique and exclusive eyeliner colors, finishes, and packaging.

Celebrity Endorsements and Eyeliner Trends

Celebrity endorsements serve as powerful marketing tools for eyeliner brands. When a celebrity is spotted wearing a specific eyeliner, it often sparks a trend and drives sales for that particular product. The influence of celebrities on makeup trends cannot be understated, as their red carpet looks and everyday makeup choices shape the beauty industry.

Eyeliner in Runway and Editorial Makeup

Eyeliner plays a significant role in runway and editorial makeup, where bold and avant-garde looks are often created. Fashion designers and makeup artists utilize eyeliner to create unique and eye-catching designs that complement their collections. This experimentation and creativity on the runway often trickle down to everyday makeup trends.

Eyeliner Recommendations for Different Occasions

Different occasions call for different eyeliner looks. Here are some recommendations based on the occasion.

Daytime and Office-Friendly Looks

For daytime and office-friendly looks, a subtle and natural eyeliner style is usually preferred. Opt for a thin line along the upper lash line using a brown or grey eyeliner for a softer look. Avoid thick or dramatic winged liner, as it can be too bold for a daytime setting. Instead, focus on defining the eyes and making them appear awake and refreshed.

Nighttime and Glamorous Looks

For nighttime and glamorous looks, feel free to go all out with your eyeliner. Experiment with different winged liner styles, such as a classic, thick wing or a graphic, extended wing for a modern twist. Consider using a liquid or gel eyeliner for more precision and intensity. Pair your liner with a smoky eye or vibrant eyeshadow for a show-stopping look.

Special Occasions

Special occasions call for special eyeliner looks. For weddings, formal events, or important celebrations, a timeless and elegant winged liner is a safe choice. Go for a subtle yet defined wing, focusing on elongating the eyes. You can also add a touch of glitter or shimmer for added glamour.

Festival and Party Makeup

Festivals and parties are the perfect opportunities to experiment with bold and creative eyeliner looks. Embrace graphic liner designs, colorful eyeliner, or unconventional shapes. Go wild and have fun with your eyeliner, as these events provide a platform for you to express your unique style and unleash your creativity.


In conclusion, eyeliner is a versatile and essential tool in every makeup enthusiast’s collection. It can enhance the eyes, create different styles and moods, and completely transform a look. After extensive research and testing, the £3 favorite emerged as a standout product, offering exceptional quality, longevity, and ease of application at an affordable price. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro, eyeliner allows you to explore your creativity and express your personal style. Remember to choose the right formula and applicator, follow some simple tips and tricks, and embrace the ever-evolving trends to make the most of your eyeliner experience.